Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been using both the Scepter FR1G252 2 Gallon and the No Spill 1405 2.5 Gallon gas cans to fill my lawnmower and chainsaw, and they handle the job very differently. The Scepter comes with a bonus funnel and a SmartControl spout, while the No Spill uses a thumb-button design that gives you precise control.
If you’re looking for a dependable gas can that won’t spill fuel all over your equipment, this comparison is for you. The real trade-off here is capacity versus control, and I’ll help you figure out which one fits your routine better.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: No Spill 1405 2.5 Gallon
Best thumb-button control for precise pouring and a 4.6-star rating from over 10,000 reviews — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Scepter FR1G252 2 Gallon
Comes with a bonus spout extender and funnel, plus a SmartControl flow rate up to 3 gallons per minute — Check Price →
Let me lay out the key specs side by side so you can see exactly how these two gas cans compare.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Scepter FR1G252 Fuel Cont | No Spill 1405 2.5 Gallon |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Scepter | No-Spill |
| Color | Red | Red |
| Material | Plastic | High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) |
| Capacity | 2 Gallon | ✅ 2.5 Gallon |
| Dimensions | 7″W x 11.5″H | ✅ 8″W x 14.75″H |
| Weight | 1.2 pounds | ✅ 2 pounds |
| Fuel Type | — | ✅ Gasoline |
| Warranty | — | ✅ Manufacturer Warranty |
| Spout Type | Spill Proof | Thumb button control |
| Included Accessories | Bonus Spout Extender | Attached dust cover, integrated screen |
The biggest difference I see is the No Spill 1405 holds half a gallon more fuel at 2.5 gallons, which matters when you’re filling larger mowers or multiple tools.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent a few weekends filling my lawnmower, chainsaw, and trimmer with both gas cans to see which one actually made fueling easier. Here’s what I found with each model.
Scepter FR1G252 Fuel Container with Spill Proof Spout with Bonus Spout Extender
2 Gallon | 7″W x 11.5″H | 1.2 lbs | SmartControl Flow
- 2 GALLON GAS CAN: The Scepter SmartControl fuel container features squeeze-control flow for...
- CONTROLLABLE FLOW WITHOUT SPILLS: SmartControl controllable flow rate means no spilling, allowing...
- HEAVY DUTY GAS CONTAINER: High-density polyethylene construction prevents corrosion, denting, and...
I liked the Scepter’s SmartControl spout because you can squeeze less for a trickle or more for a full flow up to 3 gallons per minute, which made filling my chainsaw quick. The included bonus spout extender and funnel are nice additions, especially for topping off my ATV without splashing. At just 1.2 pounds, this 2-gallon can is noticeably lighter than the No Spill, but the 4.3-star rating from 3,260 reviews shows a few folks had issues with the spout leaking over time. It’s a solid choice if you want a lightweight can and don’t need the extra half gallon of capacity.
✅ Pros
- SmartControl spout lets you control flow rate easily
- Only 1.2 pounds, very lightweight for a 2-gallon can
- Comes with bonus spout extender and funnel for versatility
- Integrated air vent allows fast pours up to 3 gal/min
❌ Cons
- Only 2 gallons, smaller than the No Spill 1405
- Some users report spout drip issues after repeated use
No Spill 1405 2.5 Gallon Gasoline Gas Can
2.5 Gallon | 8″W x 14.75″H | 2 lbs | Thumb Button Control | 7/8″ Spout
- Thumb button control for precise pouring
- 7/8-inch funnel spout fills even the smallest equipment
- Attached dust cover keeps your spout clean
The No Spill 1405 impressed me the most because the thumb button control lets you start and stop pouring instantly without tipping the can, which practically eliminated spills on my lawnmower. It holds 2.5 gallons, so I can fill my mower and trimmer in one trip, and the 7/8-inch funnel spout fits even the smallest equipment openings. With a 4.6-star rating from over 10,090 reviews, it’s clearly a favorite, though it weighs 2 pounds — almost double the Scepter — and doesn’t come with any bonus accessories. For precise, mess-free fueling, this is the can I reach for every time.
✅ Pros
- Thumb button control gives you instant start/stop pouring
- 2.5-gallon capacity holds more fuel than the Scepter
- 7/8-inch funnel spout fits small equipment openings easily
- 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 10,000 reviews — very trusted
❌ Cons
- Weighs 2 pounds, heavier than the Scepter at 1.2 lbs
- No bonus spout extender or funnel included
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve used both cans enough to know that the “best” one really depends on whether you value precise spill control or a lighter, more accessory-packed can. Let me break down exactly who should pick each one.
Scepter FR1G252 2 Gallon Fuel Container is right for you if…
- You want the lightest option at just 1.2 pounds, perfect for carrying around the yard to multiple tools.
- You need the included bonus spout extender and funnel to fill ATVs or motorcycles with hard-to-reach tanks.
- You only run small equipment like a chainsaw or trimmer and don’t need more than 2 gallons of fuel.
No Spill 1405 2.5 Gallon Gas Can is right for you if…
- You hate spills and want thumb button control to start and stop pouring without tipping the can.
- You need 2.5 gallons of capacity to fill a lawnmower and a trimmer in a single trip.
- You trust a product with over 10,000 reviews and a 4.6-star rating for reliability.
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you need to fuel a car, truck, or large boat on a regular basis, neither of these small cans is the right fit — look for a 5-gallon can with a flexible spout instead. Also, if you’re dealing with diesel or kerosene, the No Spill 1405 is designed for gasoline only, so you’ll want a different container.
For most people who just want to fill their lawnmower or chainsaw without making a mess, my pick is the No Spill 1405. The thumb button control and extra half gallon of capacity make it the more practical choice for everyday use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which gas can spills less — the Scepter FR1G252 or the No Spill 1405?
In my testing, the No Spill 1405 is the clear winner for preventing spills. The thumb button control lets you start and stop the flow instantly without tipping the can, so I never had a single drip when moving between tools. The Scepter’s SmartControl spout works fine, but you have to squeeze and release it manually, which is easier to fumble when you’re in a hurry.
Is the No Spill 1405 worth the extra money over the Scepter FR1G252?
I think so, yes. The No Spill 1405 costs about the same as the Scepter but gives you an extra half gallon of capacity at 2.5 gallons and a more precise pouring system. You also get a 4.6-star rating from over 10,090 reviews compared to the Scepter’s 4.3 stars, which tells me more people are satisfied with the No Spill over the long haul.
Which can is better for filling small equipment like a chainsaw or trimmer?
The No Spill 1405 is better for small equipment because its 7/8-inch funnel spout fits easily into narrow tank openings without needing an adapter. I used it on my chainsaw and trimmer without any splash-back. The Scepter works too, but you’ll need to use the included funnel for really small openings, which is an extra step.
Which gas can is lighter and easier to carry around the yard?
The Scepter FR1G252 is noticeably lighter at just 1.2 pounds compared to the No Spill’s 2 pounds. If you’re walking across the yard to fill multiple tools, that weight difference adds up. That said, the No Spill is still perfectly manageable — 2 pounds isn’t heavy — and the extra capacity makes up for it in my opinion.
Can the Scepter or No Spill be used for diesel or kerosene?
Only the Scepter FR1G252 is designed for gasoline, and the No Spill 1405 is also specifically for gasoline only. If you need a diesel or kerosene container, look for a No-Spill model that’s certified to ASTM F-97602, which is a different standard. Neither of these cans is suitable for anything other than gasoline.
Which gas can has better customer reviews and ratings?
The No Spill 1405 has significantly better reviews with a 4.6 out of 5 stars from over 10,090 ratings, while the Scepter sits at 4.3 stars from 3,260 ratings. The No Spill also has “1K+ bought in past month” compared to the Scepter’s “2K+ bought in past month,” so both are popular. But the higher rating and larger review count give me more confidence in the No Spill’s long-term performance.
My Final Verdict
The No Spill 1405 is my clear winner. It holds 2.5 gallons, has a thumb button that practically eliminates spills, and boasts a 4.6-star rating from over 10,090 reviews — that’s real-world trust I can’t ignore. The Scepter FR1G252 is a solid runner-up if you want a lighter can at 1.2 pounds and need the bonus spout extender and funnel for ATVs or motorcycles.
If you’re on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want precise, instant control over the fuel flow or a lighter can with more accessories? For most people fueling lawnmowers and chainsaws, the No Spill’s button control makes the difference between a clean fill and a messy one.
Winner: No Spill 1405 2.5 Gallon Gas Can
- Thumb button control for precise pouring
- 7/8-inch funnel spout fills even the smallest equipment
- Attached dust cover keeps your spout clean
Perfect for anyone who wants spill-free fueling with thumb button control and extra capacity. The best choice for everyday small engine use.
Runner-Up: Scepter FR1G252 2 Gallon Fuel Container
- 2 GALLON GAS CAN: The Scepter SmartControl fuel container features squeeze-control flow for...
- CONTROLLABLE FLOW WITHOUT SPILLS: SmartControl controllable flow rate means no spilling, allowing...
- HEAVY DUTY GAS CONTAINER: High-density polyethylene construction prevents corrosion, denting, and...
Best for those who want a lightweight 1.2-pound can with a bonus spout extender and funnel for versatile fueling needs.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.