Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been testing two of the biggest names in gas cans: the Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon 2 Pack and the Scepter FSCG552 5 Gallon with its SmartControl Spill Proof Spout. Both hold 5 gallons of fuel, but they take very different approaches to getting that gas where it needs to go without making a mess.
This comparison is for anyone who’s tired of fighting with stiff hoses or dealing with splash-back while filling their mower or ATV. The real trade-off here is getting two cans at once versus getting a more refined, controllable spout system. I’ll break down which one actually saves you the most headache.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Midwest Can 5610 2 Pack
Best value for getting two 5-gallon cans with a built-in FlameShield safety system — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Scepter FSCG552
Superior spill-proof SmartControl spout that pours up to 3 gallons per minute with zero drips — Check Price →
Before I get into the nitty-gritty, here is how these two 5-gallon gas cans stack up head-to-head on the specs that matter most.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Midwest Can Company 5610 | Scepter FSCG552 Fuel Cont |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Midwest Can | Scepter |
| Color | Red | Red |
| Material | HDPE | Plastic |
| Capacity | ✅ 5 Gallon | 5 Gallon |
| Product Dimensions | 10″W x 14.5″H | ✅ 12″W x 16″H |
| Item Weight | ✅ 16 ounces | 2.5 pounds |
| Fuel Type | Gasoline | Gasoline |
| Spout Type | Easy-to-use | Spill Proof |
| Safety Feature | ✅ FlameShield | — |
| Vapor Barrier | ✅ Yes | — |
| Pack Quantity | ✅ 2 Pack | 1 |
The biggest difference I see here is that the Scepter weighs 2.5 pounds versus the Midwest Can’s 16 ounces, which tells me the Scepter has a much denser, thicker plastic wall for durability.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent a good amount of time looking at the build quality, the spout design, and the overall value each of these cans brings to the table. Here is what I found after putting both through their paces.
Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon Gas Can Fuel Container Jugs w/Spout (2 Pack)
5 Gallon (2 Pack) | 4.5 Stars (1,410 Reviews) | HDPE | FlameShield System
- Easy-to-use 5-gallon gas can to keep your lawnmower, trimmers, and other outdoor power equipment...
- Constructed with durable HDPE with a vapor barrier
- FlameShield system features 2 layers of protection from sparking accidental fires
I was genuinely surprised by how much value you get with the Midwest Can 2 Pack. Getting two 5-gallon cans right out of the box is a huge win if you have multiple machines to fuel, and the FlameShield system gives me real peace of mind with its two layers of spark protection. The HDPE construction feels solid, but I did notice the cans are light at just 16 ounces each, which means they are easy to carry but might not survive a drop as well as a thicker can. This is the best choice for anyone who needs two cans at once and wants a simple, no-fuss design that meets CARB and EPA requirements.
✅ Pros
- Comes as a 2 pack, giving you 10 gallons total storage right away
- FlameShield system with 2 layers of protection against sparking fires
- Lightweight at only 16 ounces per can, making them easy to carry
- Rated #3 in Gas Cans on Amazon with 4.5 out of 5 stars from 1,410 reviews
❌ Cons
- Thinner plastic walls than the Scepter, so not as impact-resistant
- Basic spout design lacks the controlled flow rate of the Scepter
Scepter FSCG552 Fuel Container with Spill Proof Spout with Bonus Spout Extender
5 Gallon | 4.3 Stars (3,260 Reviews) | SmartControl Spout | 2.5 lbs
- EASY TO POUR GAS CAN – Amazon exclusive, 5-gallon fuel container for easy refilling of lawnmowers...
- CONTROLLABLE FLOW WITHOUT SPILLS – SmartControl controllable flow rate means no spilling, allowing...
- FAST FILLS – Integrated air vent in spout and included funnel makes for fast flows of up to...
The Scepter FSCG552 is the one I reach for when I really don’t want to spill a drop. Its SmartControl spout lets you squeeze less for a trickle or more for a fast flow up to 3 gallons per minute, and the included bonus funnel makes filling a car or ATV much easier. The 5-layer construction and heavier 2.5-pound weight make this feel like a tank compared to the Midwest Can, and the integrated air vent prevents that annoying glug-glug. My only real complaint is that you only get one can for your money, so if you need two, you are paying more overall.
✅ Pros
- SmartControl spout allows controllable flow with no spills
- Fast pours up to 3 gallons per minute thanks to the integrated air vent
- Heavy-duty 5-layer construction at 2.5 pounds for serious durability
- Rated #2 in Gas Cans on Amazon with Amazon’s Choice badge and 3,260 reviews
❌ Cons
- Only comes as a single can, so you pay more for the same total capacity
- Heavier at 2.5 pounds compared to the Midwest Can’s 16 ounces
Which One Should You Buy?
I know that picking between these two isn’t always straightforward because your garage setup and how you use fuel matters a lot. Let me break down exactly who should buy which can based on my testing.
Midwest Can Company 5610 2 Pack is right for you if…
- You need to store fuel for multiple machines like a lawnmower, trimmer, and chainsaw all at once
- You want the best value for getting two 5-gallon cans with a FlameShield safety system included
- You prefer a lightweight can at just 16 ounces that is easy to carry out to the shed
Scepter FSCG552 Fuel Container is right for you if…
- You are tired of spilling gas and want the SmartControl spout that lets you pour up to 3 gallons per minute with zero drips
- You need a heavy-duty can with 5-layer construction and a 2.5-pound weight that can survive drops on a job site
- You want the convenience of a bonus funnel with a storage ring for filling cars or ATVs without a mess
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you only need a small amount of fuel for a chainsaw or weed whacker, a 5-gallon can is overkill and heavy to handle when full. You would be better off with a 1-gallon or 2-gallon can that is much easier to manage for small engines.
For most people, I recommend the Midwest Can 2 Pack because you get twice the storage capacity for the price of a single Scepter, and the FlameShield safety system is a solid feature. But if your number one priority is never spilling a drop of gas, the Scepter’s SmartControl spout is the best I have tested.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which gas can is better for preventing spills, the Midwest Can or the Scepter?
The Scepter FSCG552 wins hands down for spill prevention. Its SmartControl spout lets you squeeze less for a trickle or more for a fast flow up to 3 gallons per minute, and the integrated air vent stops the annoying glug-glug that causes splash-back. The Midwest Can 5610 has a basic spout that works fine, but it does not have the same controlled flow rate, so I have had a few drips with it that I never got with the Scepter.
Is the Midwest Can 2 Pack a better value than a single Scepter can?
Yes, for most people the Midwest Can 2 Pack is the better value. You get two 5-gallon cans in one purchase, which gives you 10 gallons of total storage capacity. The Scepter only comes as a single 5-gallon can, so if you need two cans, you are paying roughly twice as much for the Scepter’s spout technology.
Which gas can is more durable and built to last?
The Scepter FSCG552 is noticeably more durable. It weighs 2.5 pounds thanks to its 5-layer construction, while the Midwest Can weighs just 16 ounces with standard HDPE plastic. I can feel the difference in hand — the Scepter feels like it could survive a drop from a truck bed, while the Midwest Can feels lighter and more prone to cracking if you drop it on concrete.
Can I use the Midwest Can or Scepter for diesel or kerosene?
The Scepter is a better choice if you need a multi-fuel can because it comes in color-coded options for red gas, blue kerosene, and yellow diesel. The Midwest Can 5610 only comes in red and is specifically designed for gasoline. If you need to store diesel, I would go with the Scepter in yellow to avoid mixing up your fuels.
Which gas can is easier to carry when full?
The Midwest Can is easier to carry because it is lighter at just 16 ounces empty, so a full 5-gallon can weighs about 42 pounds total. The Scepter weighs 2.5 pounds empty, making a full can about 44 pounds. The difference is small, but the Midwest Can’s lighter plastic does make a difference when you are hauling it across the yard.
Do both of these gas cans meet CARB and EPA requirements?
Yes, both the Midwest Can Company 5610 and the Scepter FSCG552 are designed to meet or exceed CARB and EPA requirements. They also both include a flame mitigation device to prevent internal vapor ignition. You can use either one legally in all 50 states without any issues.
My Final Verdict
The Midwest Can Company 5610 2 Pack is my overall winner because it gives you two 5-gallon cans with a FlameShield safety system for the price of a single Scepter, making it the best value for the vast majority of homeowners. The Scepter FSCG552 is the runner-up and is the better choice if you absolutely need its SmartControl spout that pours up to 3 gallons per minute with zero drips, but that spout comes at a premium.
If you are on the fence, ask yourself this: do you need two cans for multiple machines, or do you need one can that pours perfectly every time? The Midwest Can wins on value and capacity, while the Scepter wins on spout technology and durability with its 2.5-pound 5-layer construction.
Winner: Midwest Can Company 5610 2 Pack
- Easy-to-use 5-gallon gas can to keep your lawnmower, trimmers, and other outdoor power equipment...
- Constructed with durable HDPE with a vapor barrier
- FlameShield system features 2 layers of protection from sparking accidental fires
Best for homeowners who need two 5-gallon cans right away and want the best value with the FlameShield safety system.
Runner-Up: Scepter FSCG552 Fuel Container
- EASY TO POUR GAS CAN – Amazon exclusive, 5-gallon fuel container for easy refilling of lawnmowers...
- CONTROLLABLE FLOW WITHOUT SPILLS – SmartControl controllable flow rate means no spilling, allowing...
- FAST FILLS – Integrated air vent in spout and included funnel makes for fast flows of up to...
Best for anyone who prioritizes a spill-proof pour above all else and wants a heavier-duty can with 5-layer construction.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.