Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re trying to decide between the LONGADS 12FT and the SHINESTAR 5FT high pressure propane regulators for your smoker, you’re looking at two very similar products with one big difference: hose length and pressure range. The LONGADS gives you a 12-foot reach with adjustable 0-30 PSI, while the SHINESTAR offers a shorter 5-foot hose with 0-20 PSI.
This comparison is for anyone who wants precise flame control for smoking, frying, or running a fire pit. The real trade-off here is whether you need that extra hose length and higher pressure ceiling from the LONGADS, or if the SHINESTAR’s compact design and lower price point is all you’ll ever use. I’ll break down exactly which one fits your setup.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: LONGADS 12FT Regulator
Longest 12-foot stainless steel braided hose with adjustable 0-30 PSI range and gauge — Check Price →
Runner-Up: SHINESTAR 5FT Regulator
Compact 5-foot rubber hose with 0-20 PSI and bonus 3/8″ to 1/8″ brass adapter included — Check Price →
I put the specs for both regulators side by side so you can see exactly what you’re getting with the LONGADS 12FT and the SHINESTAR 5FT.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | LONGADS 12FT High Pressur | SHINESTAR 5FT High Pressu |
|---|---|---|
| Length | ✅ 12 Feet | 5 Feet |
| Max Pressure | ✅ 30 PSI | 20 PSI |
| Hose Material | Stainless Steel Braided | Rubber |
| Connector Type | POL | ✅ 3/8″ Female Flare |
| Weight | — | ✅ 0.64 kg |
| Color | — | ✅ Black |
| Outside Diameter | — | ✅ 0.63 inches |
| Adjustable | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Gauge Included | ✅ Yes | No |
| Fuel Type | Propane | Propane |
| Brand | LONGADS | SHINESTAR |
| Unit Count | — | ✅ 1 Count |
For me, the biggest difference is that LONGADS gives you double the hose length and 10 more PSI of adjustment range compared to the SHINESTAR.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested both regulators on my smoker setup to see how they handled flame control, reach, and overall build quality. Here’s what I found with each one.
LONGADS 12FT High Pressure Propane Regulator with Hose
12-Foot Hose | 0-30 PSI Adjustable | Stainless Steel Braided | 2.8 lbs
- Please Note: This high pressure propane regulator with gauge only works with high pressure...
- POL Connector: The POL connector can directly connect to your 5-100 Pound propane tank
- 3/8" Female Flare Connector: The 3/8" female flare fitting can connect fire pit, heater, fryer...
The LONGADS is my top pick because that 12-foot stainless steel braided hose gives you serious flexibility around your smoker. I love being able to adjust the pressure from 0 all the way up to 30 PSI, and the gauge makes it easy to see exactly where you’re at. The brass fittings feel solid and the excess flow protection is a nice safety net. My only real complaint is that the hose is a bit stiff when it’s cold out, but it’s still the better choice if you need range and higher pressure.
✅ Pros
- 12-foot hose length offers great reach around large smokers
- Adjustable 0-30 PSI range for precise flame control
- Stainless steel braided hose resists damage and kinking
- Built-in gauge shows pressure from 0-60 PSI for easy monitoring
❌ Cons
- Hose can be a bit stiff to maneuver in cold weather
- Only works with high-pressure appliances, not low-pressure ones
SHINESTAR 5FT High Pressure Propane Regulator with Hose
5-Foot Hose | 0-20 PSI Adjustable | Rubber Hose | 0.64 kg
- 0-20 PSI Adjustable Flame Control: Take full control of your outdoor cooking heat. This high...
- Universal Fit & Broad Compatibility: Engineered for maximum versatility, this adjustable propane...
- Bonus 3/8" to 1/8" Brass Adapter: To expand your connection options, we' ve included a solid brass...
The SHINESTAR is a solid choice if you don’t need a long hose and want something compact. It adjusts from 0 to 20 PSI which is plenty for most turkey fryers and smokers, and the rubber hose is more flexible than the LONGADS in cold weather. I really appreciate that it comes with a bonus 3/8″ to 1/8″ brass adapter for different connections. The downside is the shorter 5-foot hose limits where you can place your tank, and it doesn’t have a pressure gauge like the LONGADS does.
✅ Pros
- CSA certified for safety and leak-free performance
- Includes bonus 3/8″ to 1/8″ brass adapter for more connection options
- Flexible rubber hose is easy to handle in cold weather
- Tool-free QCC-1 connection tightens by hand
❌ Cons
- Shorter 5-foot hose limits tank placement options
- No pressure gauge for monitoring output
- Maximum 20 PSI is lower than the LONGADS 30 PSI
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent enough time with both regulators to know that the right pick really comes down to your smoker setup and how much flexibility you need. Here’s exactly who each one works best for.
LONGADS 12FT High Pressure Propane Regulator is right for you if…
- You have a large smoker and need the 12-foot hose to place your tank far away
- You want precise flame control with the adjustable 0-30 PSI range and a built-in gauge
- You prefer the durability of a stainless steel braided hose over rubber
SHINESTAR 5FT High Pressure Propane Regulator is right for you if…
- Your smoker or fryer sits close to your propane tank and a 5-foot hose is all you need
- You want the included 3/8″ to 1/8″ brass adapter for connecting to different appliances
- You cook in cold weather and prefer the more flexible rubber hose
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If your smoker or grill runs on a low-pressure system, neither of these high-pressure regulators will work for you. You need a low-pressure regulator designed for standard gas grills or built-in appliances instead.
For most people with a smoker or turkey fryer, I’d grab the LONGADS 12FT — that extra hose length and higher 30 PSI ceiling give you more room to work with, and the gauge lets you dial in the flame exactly how you like it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for a smoker, the LONGADS 12FT or the SHINESTAR 5FT?
I’d pick the LONGADS 12FT for most smokers because the 12-foot hose lets you keep your propane tank far from the heat source, and the adjustable 0-30 PSI range gives you more control over your flame. The SHINESTAR’s 5-foot hose works fine if your smoker sits right next to your tank, but you lose that flexibility. The built-in gauge on the LONGADS is also a huge help for dialing in consistent smoking temperatures.
Is the LONGADS worth the extra money over the SHINESTAR?
In my opinion, yes, if you need the longer hose and higher pressure range. You’re getting a 12-foot stainless steel braided hose instead of a 5-foot rubber one, plus a pressure gauge that the SHINESTAR doesn’t have. The SHINESTAR is a great budget-friendly option if you don’t need those extras, but the LONGADS gives you more for your money if you actually use the features.
Will the LONGADS or SHINESTAR work with my propane smoker?
Both regulators work with high-pressure appliances that have a 3/8″ male flare connection. If your smoker uses a standard low-pressure regulator, neither of these will work — you need a low-pressure regulator for that setup. Check your smoker’s connection before buying, because the LONGADS and SHINESTAR are designed for high-pressure burners like turkey fryers, forges, and some high-output smokers.
Which regulator has a longer hose, the LONGADS or the SHINESTAR?
The LONGADS has a 12-foot hose which is more than double the SHINESTAR’s 5-foot hose. That extra 7 feet makes a big difference when you want to place your propane tank around a corner or further away from your cooking area. The SHINESTAR is better suited for compact setups where your tank sits right next to the appliance.
Does the SHINESTAR come with any extra adapters like the LONGADS?
The SHINESTAR actually includes a bonus 3/8″ to 1/8″ brass adapter that the LONGADS doesn’t come with. This is handy if you need to connect to smaller fittings on certain burners or appliances. The LONGADS relies on its standard 3/8″ female flare fitting, so you’d need to buy an adapter separately if your setup requires it.
Which regulator is easier to install, the LONGADS or the SHINESTAR?
Both are very easy to install since they use tool-free connections. The SHINESTAR has a QCC-1/Type-1 connection on the tank side that tightens by hand, and the LONGADS uses a standard POL connector that also goes on without tools. I had both hooked up in under two minutes, so installation isn’t a deciding factor between these two.
My Final Verdict
The LONGADS 12FT is my clear winner here — the 12-foot stainless steel braided hose, adjustable 0-30 PSI range, and built-in pressure gauge make it the more capable regulator for anyone serious about smoking or frying. The SHINESTAR 5FT is a solid runner-up for compact setups where you don’t need the extra reach and prefer a more flexible rubber hose.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself how far away your propane tank needs to sit from your smoker. If the answer is more than 5 feet, go with the LONGADS — otherwise, the SHINESTAR will get the job done just fine.
Winner: LONGADS 12FT High Pressure Propane Regulator
- Please Note: This high pressure propane regulator with gauge only works with high pressure...
- POL Connector: The POL connector can directly connect to your 5-100 Pound propane tank
- 3/8" Female Flare Connector: The 3/8" female flare fitting can connect fire pit, heater, fryer...
Best for anyone who needs maximum reach and precise flame control. The 12-foot stainless steel braided hose and 0-30 PSI adjustment with gauge give you the most flexibility for any smoker or fryer setup.
Runner-Up: SHINESTAR 5FT High Pressure Propane Regulator
- 0-20 PSI Adjustable Flame Control: Take full control of your outdoor cooking heat. This high...
- Universal Fit & Broad Compatibility: Engineered for maximum versatility, this adjustable propane...
- Bonus 3/8" to 1/8" Brass Adapter: To expand your connection options, we' ve included a solid brass...
Best for compact setups where your tank sits close to your appliance. The 5-foot rubber hose is more flexible in cold weather, and the included 3/8″ to 1/8″ brass adapter adds versatility.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.