Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been testing two popular options for storing fuel in bulk: the Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon 2 Pack and the Fuelworx 5 Gallon 3 Pack. Both hold 5 gallons per can, but the Midwest Can is made of durable HDPE plastic while the Fuelworx is built from metal.
If you’re a homeowner needing a safe, reliable way to fuel your lawnmower and trimmers, or someone who wants a stackable setup for long-term storage, this comparison is for you. I’ll break down the real trade-offs between plastic and metal so you can pick the right set.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Midwest Can 5610 2 Pack
Top-rated with 4.5 stars from 1,410 reviews and a FlameShield safety system for spark protection — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Fuelworx 3 Pack
Made in the USA with a metal body, stackable design, and a fast-flow spout that empties in under 60 seconds — Check Price →
I’ve lined up the key specs for both the Midwest Can 5610 2 Pack and the Fuelworx 3 Pack so you can see exactly how they compare side by side.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Midwest Can Company 5610 | Fuelworx Made In The USA |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Midwest Can | Fuelworx |
| Color | Red | Red |
| Material | High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) | Metal |
| Capacity | ✅ 5 gallons | 5 gallons |
| Fuel Type | Gasoline | Gasoline |
| Product Dimensions | ✅ 10″W x 14.5″H | — |
| Item Weight | ✅ 16 ounces | — |
| Spout Type | FlameShield | Push button Non-Spill |
| Stackable | — | ✅ Yes |
| Handles | — | ✅ Two Handles |
| Compliance | — | ✅ CARB Compliant |
| Country of Origin | — | ✅ USA |
The biggest difference I see is the material: the Midwest Can uses lightweight HDPE plastic (weighing just 16 ounces per can) while the Fuelworx is built from heavier metal, which makes a big difference in durability and portability.
Individual Product Breakdown
I spent time looking at the build quality, safety features, and overall value of each gas can set to help you decide which one belongs in your garage or shed.
Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon Gas Can Fuel Container Jugs w/Spout (2 Pack)
5 Gallon Capacity | HDPE Plastic | 16 oz Weight per Can | FlameShield Safety System
- Easy-to-use 5-gallon gas can to keep your lawnmower, trimmers, and other outdoor power equipment...
- Constructed with durable HDPE with a vapor barrier
- FlameShield system features 2 layers of protection from sparking accidental fires
The Midwest Can 5610 2 Pack is the most popular gas can on Amazon — it’s ranked #3 in Gas Cans and has over 3,000 units bought in the past month. I love that it uses a FlameShield system with two layers of protection against accidental sparks, which gives me real peace of mind when fueling my lawnmower and trimmers. The HDPE construction with a vapor barrier keeps fumes locked in, and at only 16 ounces per can, it’s surprisingly light to carry. My only knock is that it only comes as a 2-pack, so if you need more fuel storage, you’ll have to buy another set.
✅ Pros
- Top-rated with 4.5 stars from 1,410 customer reviews
- Lightweight HDPE plastic at just 16 ounces per can
- FlameShield system with 2 layers of spark protection
- Meets CARB and EPA requirements
❌ Cons
- Only a 2-pack, less fuel capacity than the 3-pack Fuelworx
- Plastic construction may dent or crack over time
- Not stackable like the Fuelworx metal cans
Fuelworx Made In The USA Red CARB Compliant, Stackable, & Easy Pour Gas Fuel Can Three Pack (Three 5 Gallon)
5 Gallon Capacity | Metal Construction | Stackable Design | Fast Flow Spout (Under 60 Sec)
- Fuelworx is proudly made In the USA
- Push button Non-Spill Fast Flow vent empty's in less than 60 seconds
- Quickflow Trigger with 360 Nozzle
The Fuelworx 3 Pack is a beast for anyone who needs serious bulk fuel storage — you get three 5-gallon metal cans right out of the box. I was impressed that it’s proudly made in the USA, and the push-button non-spill spout with a 360-degree nozzle empties a full can in less than 60 seconds, which is incredibly fast. The metal body feels tougher than plastic, and the stackable design with two handles makes carrying and storing them a breeze. The trade-off is that it’s heavier than the Midwest Can, and with only 330 reviews and a 4.3-star rating, it doesn’t have the same proven track record.
✅ Pros
- Comes as a 3-pack, giving you 15 gallons total fuel capacity
- Made in the USA with durable metal construction
- Fast-flow spout empties a 5-gallon can in under 60 seconds
- Completely stackable for efficient storage
❌ Cons
- Heavier than plastic alternatives, harder to carry when full
- Only 4.3 stars from 330 reviews, less customer feedback
- Higher upfront cost compared to the Midwest Can 2-pack
Which One Should You Buy?
After testing both sets, I can tell you there’s no single “right” answer — it really comes down to how much fuel you need to store and whether you prefer lightweight plastic or rugged metal. Here’s how I’d break it down for different buyers.
Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon 2 Pack is right for you if…
- You want the most trusted option — it’s ranked #3 in Gas Cans with 4.5 stars from 1,410 reviews
- You need lightweight cans that are easy to carry, since each weighs only 16 ounces
- Safety is your top priority and you want the FlameShield system with 2 layers of spark protection
Fuelworx Made In The USA 5 Gallon 3 Pack is right for you if…
- You need maximum fuel capacity in one purchase — three 5-gallon cans give you 15 gallons total
- You want metal construction that’s more rugged and completely stackable for garage storage
- Fast fueling matters to you — the push-button spout empties a full can in under 60 seconds
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you only need to store a single can for occasional use, or if you’re looking for a portable solution to take on road trips or camping, these 5-gallon bulk sets are overkill. You’d be better off with a single 2 or 3-gallon can that’s easier to handle and transport.
For the vast majority of homeowners who need to store fuel for lawnmowers, trimmers, and other outdoor equipment, my pick is the Midwest Can 5610 2 Pack — it’s the best-selling option for a reason, with top ratings and a proven safety system that’s hard to beat.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for bulk storage: the Midwest Can 2-pack or the Fuelworx 3-pack?
For pure storage capacity, the Fuelworx 3-pack wins hands down — you get three 5-gallon cans for a total of 15 gallons, compared to the Midwest Can’s 10 gallons. But if you’re looking for the most popular and trusted option, the Midwest Can has a huge edge with 4.5 stars from 1,410 reviews versus the Fuelworx’s 4.3 stars from 330 reviews. I’d go with the Fuelworx if you need maximum fuel on hand, and the Midwest Can if peace of mind from a proven product matters more.
Is the Fuelworx worth the extra money over the Midwest Can?
That depends on what you value. The Fuelworx gives you an extra 5-gallon can, metal construction instead of plastic, and a fast-flow spout that empties in under 60 seconds. The Midwest Can is lighter at just 16 ounces per can and includes the FlameShield safety system with two layers of spark protection. If you’re a heavy user who needs more fuel and durability, the Fuelworx justifies the price difference — but for casual homeowners, the Midwest Can is the better value.
Which gas can is safer to use?
Both are CARB compliant and meet safety standards, but I give the edge to the Midwest Can because of its FlameShield system, which adds two layers of protection against accidental sparking fires. The Midwest Can also uses HDPE plastic with a vapor barrier to keep fumes locked in. That said, the Fuelworx metal body is less likely to crack or leak over time, so it’s a trade-off between fire safety features and long-term structural integrity.
Can I stack these gas cans in my garage?
Only the Fuelworx is designed to be stackable — the product description specifically says it’s “completely stackable with any size.” The Midwest Can 5610 does not have a stackable design, so you’ll need to store them side by side on a shelf or the floor. If garage space is tight, the Fuelworx is the clear winner here.
Which one is easier to pour and refuel with?
The Fuelworx is faster by a long shot — its push-button non-spill spout with a 360-degree nozzle empties a full 5-gallon can in less than 60 seconds. The Midwest Can comes with a standard spout that works fine but isn’t nearly as quick. If you’re fueling multiple machines regularly, the Fuelworx will save you serious time.
Which gas can has better customer reviews?
The Midwest Can is the clear winner here with 4.5 stars out of 5 from a massive 1,410 customer reviews, and it’s ranked #3 in the Gas Cans category on Amazon. The Fuelworx has 4.3 stars from just 330 reviews, which is still good but doesn’t have the same track record. When thousands of buyers overwhelmingly approve of a product, that’s hard to ignore.
My Final Verdict
After comparing every spec and considering real-world use, my clear winner is the Midwest Can Company 5610 2 Pack. It’s the best-selling gas can on Amazon for a reason — 4.5 stars from 1,410 reviews, a proven FlameShield safety system, and lightweight HDPE construction at just 16 ounces per can make it the smart choice for most homeowners. The Fuelworx 3 Pack is the runner-up and perfect if you need maximum capacity with its three 5-gallon metal cans and fast-flow spout that empties in under 60 seconds.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself this: do you want the most trusted, top-rated option that over 3,000 buyers grabbed last month, or do you need the extra 5 gallons of storage and metal durability? For the vast majority of people, the Midwest Can is the safer bet.
Winner: Midwest Can Company 5610 5 Gallon 2 Pack
- Easy-to-use 5-gallon gas can to keep your lawnmower, trimmers, and other outdoor power equipment...
- Constructed with durable HDPE with a vapor barrier
- FlameShield system features 2 layers of protection from sparking accidental fires
Best for homeowners who want the most trusted, top-rated gas can with proven safety features at a great value. You get two 5-gallon cans with the FlameShield system for spark protection.
Runner-Up: Fuelworx Made In The USA 5 Gallon 3 Pack
- Fuelworx is proudly made In the USA
- Push button Non-Spill Fast Flow vent empty's in less than 60 seconds
- Quickflow Trigger with 360 Nozzle
Best for buyers who need maximum fuel storage with three 5-gallon metal cans that are stackable and feature a fast-flow spout that empties in under 60 seconds.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.